Warm wall sconces illuminate burgundy seats and a cropped stage curtain in an intimate community theater, with understated evergreen decoration.

St. James's Old Calderone Theatre Is Being Rebuilt Between Shows. Its Holiday Season Is the Payoff.

The building at 176 Second Street started as a vaudeville house in the 1920s and later showed movies. It was part of the Calderone movie theater chain, and the name stuck. On Friday, November 20, at 8 p.m., a London workhouse moves onto its stage when Lighthouse Theatre Company opens Oliver!. That starts a ten-day run that covers Thanksgiving week.

Over the past two years the Calderone has never really closed its doors and waited for a finished renovation. The work has gone in stages, each paid for separately, and shows have run between them. This holiday season shows the building working as what its founders planned: a community center that happens to have a stage. The restoration isn't finished, and that's part of why the season is worth following.

The Town Bought It, and a Local Nonprofit Took On the Work

In December 2024, the Smithtown Town Board voted unanimously to let Supervisor Ed Wehrheim buy the Calderone for $900,000. The same vote let him give a 10-year lease to Celebrate St. James, the nonprofit arts group that would renovate it, as TBR News Media reported. The sale came from Natalie Weinstein, a founder of the organization.

The town owns the building, and the nonprofit pays for the work. Wehrheim told TBR that the group's "intention is to do some major renovations on the theater, and that will be paid for by them." He called the project "a really nice addition to the business district."

Jack Ader, Arline Goldstein and Weinstein founded Celebrate St. James in 2017. Its stated mission is to preserve St. James history and build knowledge and appreciation of the arts in the community. Weinstein is founder and president, Ader is founder and executive vice president, and Tami Vitebski runs programs and education. Because a small nonprofit pays for each phase, the work comes one grant or donation at a time.

A Restoration Done in Pieces

Here is the sequence so far, based on reporting from TBR and Newsday and the organization's own announcements.

Stage What it covered How it was paid for
Early work Uncovering the building's tin ceiling and opening up the stage Not specified
Phase one New roof, solar panels, lift elevator $211,000 grant from the Robert David Lion Gardiner Foundation
June 10, 2026 Ribbon cutting with town and county officials —
Phase two, starting in August New heating and air conditioning, lighting, new bathrooms, interior upgrades $200,000 private donation
October 17, 2026 "Oh, What a Night… A Broadway Celebration!" billed as the grand reopening Fundraising performance

The June ribbon cutting, as TBR described it, was framed as a milestone in an "ongoing restoration" rather than a finish line. Guests toured the space and heard Solomon Buchman from South Pacific. They also got a preview of Shadows Rise, an original rock musical about the Culper Spy Ring that premiered July 10 through 12 for America's 250th anniversary. Officials at the event included Supervisor Wehrheim, Suffolk County Legislator Sal Formica, Suffolk County Clerk Vincent Puleo, Councilwoman Lisa Inzerillo, Councilman Tom Lohmann, Town Parks Director Joseph Arico and Nissequogue Village Mayor Richard Smith.

Phase two shows how tight the schedule is. The theater closed in August for the mechanical work. By mid-September, Newsday reported that Weinstein was "sweating the deadline" on the bathroom and HVAC update, with Lighthouse's The Addams Family due to open that week. The same article said many of the building's historic artifacts would move across the street to another building recently donated to the organization. The organization billed the October fundraiser as both a celebration of "our beautifully renovated space" and a way of "supporting the continued restoration and programming of the historic theatre." Even the reopening night raised money for the next round of work.

What the Building Is Meant to Do

Weinstein has been direct about the goal. Talking to Newsday, she described the Calderone as "a community center as well as a theater" and said:

"It's about the life of the community that's been missing. The goal is to be able to promote local talent in the fields of art, music and theater ... to give people an outlet that cannot be satisfied in any other way."

She told Newsday the work has two aims at once: "While it's important to maintain the building's historic value, we also have to bring it into the 21st century."

The program already reaches past the main stage. TBR lists theater, art exhibits, concerts, community art classes and summer workshops in the building. Lighthouse, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit and the center's resident theater company, partners with charities on its productions. Its artistic director, Tony Chiofalo, opened the theater with Anastasia last year. He told Newsday "it's a charming space" and said its intimacy pushes him to find creative ways to handle the large casts musicals call for. His next show is a Dickens musical full of workhouse orphans and pickpockets.

Oliver! Runs Through Thanksgiving Week

Oliver! plays at the Celebrate St. James Center for the Arts from Friday, November 20 through Sunday, November 29. Performances fall around the holiday like this:

  • Friday, Nov. 20: 8 p.m., opening night
  • Saturday, Nov. 21: 2 p.m. and 8 p.m.
  • Sunday, Nov. 22: 2 p.m. and 7 p.m.
  • Wednesday, Nov. 25: 8 p.m., the night before Thanksgiving
  • Friday, Nov. 27: 8 p.m.
  • Saturday, Nov. 28: 2 p.m. and 8 p.m.
  • Sunday, Nov. 29: 2 p.m. and 7 p.m.

Tickets are $35 for adults, $32 for seniors and $25 for children 12 and under, per TBR's calendar listing. Sales go through Lighthouse Theatre Company's website, which links to its ThunderTix box office. Lighthouse's main page lists Oliver! through December 6 because the production then moves to Freeport for December 4 through 6. The St. James run ends November 29.

The schedule gives two matinees on each weekend, an evening show for anyone home early before Thanksgiving, and a Friday night for families who still have relatives in town afterward.

The First Weekend of December, Within a Few Miles

Once Oliver! closes, the next date on Second Street is a fundraiser, which suits a building that has relied on them. Paws of War had planned to premiere the holiday film Christmas at the Interlaken at the center on November 6. Paws of War now lists it for Friday, December 4. That night opens a full holiday weekend nearby.

Date Event Where Time
Friday, Dec. 4 Christmas at the Interlaken movie premiere and fundraiser, benefiting Paws of War Celebrate St. James Center for the Arts, 176 Second St. 7 to 10 p.m.
Saturday, Dec. 5 Deep Wells Tree Lighting Deep Wells Farm 4 to 6 p.m.
Sunday, Dec. 6 47th Annual Holiday Festival, Ward Melville Heritage Organization Stony Brook Village Hours not yet posted

Tickets for the premiere are linked from the Paws of War events page. The Deep Wells date comes from the Smithtown Rotary's calendar. The Stony Brook festival is on the Stony Brook Village events page.

For updates from the theater itself, including what comes after the premiere, check Celebrate St. James, 631-984-0201. The organization's own description of the June ribbon cutting called the building "more than a theater" and "a hub for connection, creativity, and community impact across St. James and surrounding neighborhoods." Over the next three weeks, a family can see Oliver! at Thanksgiving, come back for a film premiere on December 4, and walk out into the first weekend of the holiday season.

The Calderone's restoration follows a pattern we see in older homes all over the North Shore: fix the roof and systems first, then update what people see, and keep the building in use the whole time. If your house has its own list of phased projects to finish before a sale, Bona Fide Fine Homes & Estates and our in-house Bona Fide Services team can sequence the work and the marketing together. Schedule a List & Launch Consultation and we'll go through it room by room with you.

Work With Us

The Team at Bona Fide Fine Homes & Estates bring home sales expertise as well as services to get sellers ready to sell and help buyers with a timeline of necessary renovations before moving in across the Nassau & Suffolk Counties.

Follow Me on Instagram